The 3 Best Pizzerias Around Glenwood Springs

Pizza remains one of the most adaptable staples in American dining, balancing tradition with constant reinvention. From hand-tossed classics to fast-casual customization, pizzerias now reflect the pace and preferences of their communities. In the Roaring Fork and Colorado River valleys, that means everything from family-friendly gathering spots to quick-service options built for busy schedules. The Post Independent’s Locals’ Choice contest highlights how local pizza shops continue to evolve while staying rooted in consistency and quality.

Hogback Pizza

Hogback Pizza in New Castle focuses on traditional hand-tossed pies, supported by house-made dough and fresh ingredients. The menu includes calzones, oven-baked subs and salads, along with a mix of classic and specialty pizzas. Its downtown location positions it as a regular gathering place for residents and families. The business also maintains involvement in local events and school programs, reinforcing its role within the community.

White House Pizza

White House Pizza in Carbondale offers a broad menu that extends beyond pizza to include pasta dishes and appetizers, all built around a scratch-made approach. The restaurant accommodates a range of dietary preferences with options like gluten-free crusts and varied toppings. Operating out of a converted historic home, the space adds a distinct setting to the dining experience. Live music and community events are integrated into its regular operations, contributing to its presence in the local scene.

ZA Pizza

ZA Pizza in Glenwood Springs uses a build-your-own model that emphasizes speed and customization. Customers select from a variety of toppings and sauces, creating pizzas tailored to individual preferences. The menu also includes fresh salads and locally sourced desserts, aligning with a streamlined fast-casual format. Its location and service style make it a practical option for both residents and visitors moving through the area.

Created or enhanced with ChatGPT.